A concerned Malaysian writes about Malaysian affairs. "You are the Change you Seek" Barack Obama
Friday, December 28, 2007
malaysiakini's Summary on the IPCMC and SCC
(click2 on table to see details)
The MSM appears to have avoided any critical assessment on the proposed SCC but I guess that should not surprise anyone.
So this article from malaysiakini entitled "SCC vs IPCMC: Check out the difference" gives an interesting comparison between the original IPCMC and the new SCC.
The basic result of the 2-year delay by the authorities appears to be a watered-down commission that gives some measure of a complaints bureau but provides more of a pressure-relief mechanism by which the PM can practise "political tai-chi".
I have done a simple comparison of the 2 commissions as follows:
Each of the main components has been allocated a weighed value percentage to make up 100% for the seven main features.
Each feature is then given a score based on a maximum score of 10 points. The higher the score the more effective the feature compared between the two commissions.
The score is then multiplied by the weightage to get a weighted score.
The scores are then added to obtain the final score at the bottom of the table.
This is not a claim to being right. You can do your own analysis to see if the authorities have improved on the IPCMC or simply doing some "window dressing".